Free guide · 4-minute read

Bring back the customers who forgot you.

Every past customer who forgets you is a sale you already paid to win. Next time, they may just ask Google or ChatGPT and get someone else's name. Here are the 3 emails that bring them back, ready to copy.

First · 5 minutes

Find your number.

Pull up your customer list from the last 2 years: your booking app, your POS or a spreadsheet. Count how many people came back at least once.

That's your comeback rate. Write it down. Every email below is about moving that number.

$3,000 if 20 more people came back once.An illustration, not a promise. Plug in your own numbers.
Email 1 · 1 to 2 days after the visit

The thank-you.

Use their name and say what you did. Add one easy ask, like a Google review. Ask everyone the same way.

Example · hair salon
Subject: Thanks for coming in, MariaMaria, Thanks for coming in on Tuesday. Your color came out great. If you have a minute, would you leave us a quick Google review? It helps people in Pasadena find us. [your review link] Ana, Glow Studio
Example business. Made up for this guide.
Email 2 · when they'd normally need you again

The "you're due" email.

Say how long it's been and why now. Give one easy way to book.

BusinessGood starting point
Hair or nail salon6 to 8 weeks
Dog groomer4 to 8 weeks
Restaurant3 to 4 weeks
LandscaperEach season
Insurance agent30 days before renewal
Real estate agentEach home anniversary
LawyerOnce a year, to check in and ask for referrals

Starting points, not rules. Use what fits your customers.

Example · dog groomer
Subject: Time for Bella's next groom?Jen, It's been 6 weeks since Bella's last groom. That's about when the tangles start. Want to book her next one? We have Thursday at 10 open. [booking link] Happy Paws Grooming
Example business. Made up for this guide.
Email 3 · no visit in a year

The "we miss you" email.

Keep it short and personal, with one easy next step. You don't need a big discount.

Example · landscaper
Subject: It's been a year, DaveDave, It's been a year since we redid your yard. Spring is when we like to check the sprinklers and the new plants. Want us to stop by? Just pick a day here: [booking link] Green Ridge Landscaping
Example business. Made up for this guide.
Before you send

Four rules.

  • One person, one email, about their own visit. Never the same blast to everyone.
  • Marketing emails need an honest From name and subject line, your business address, a note that it's an ad, and an unsubscribe link. That's the law (CAN-SPAM).
  • When someone unsubscribes, stop. Right away, everywhere you send from.
  • Track it. Count how many past customers come back each month. That's your number to beat.
Done for you

Writing a different email for every customer is the hard part. We do it for you.

Email Butler writes each past customer their own email about their last visit, and sends it when they're due back. It asks every customer for a review too, which can help you rank on Google. You never write a word.

See my free sample emails Free. Just give us your website. No card needed.

Sources

  1. FTC, CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business.
  2. FTC, Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers (rule final Aug 2024).

This guide is general information, not legal advice.