Free guide · 4-minute read

Your repeat buyers decide if your store survives.

In 2022, brands lost $29 on each new customer, up from $9 in 2013 (SimplicityDX). The first order often loses money. The second order is where stores win or lose. Here's how to get it.

Why it matters

LTV decides who wins.

LTV is how much a customer spends with you over time. The higher it is, the more you can pay for each ad and still make money. If a competitor's buyers come back and yours don't, they can outbid you for the same buyer, every day.

$29lost on each new customer, up from $9 in 2013SimplicityDX, Jul 2022
25–95%more profit from keeping just 5% more online customersBain & Company, 2000
41%of email sales come from automatic emails, which are about 5% of sendsKlaviyo, 2026

The first order often loses money. The second order is where stores win or lose.

First · 2 minutes

Know your number.

In Shopify, go to Analytics, then Reports. Open "Returning customers." It lists every buyer with 2 or more orders. Then open "One-time customers." Compare the two.

Write it down and check it every month. Every email below is about moving that number.

$3,000 if 50 more buyers ordered again.An illustration, not a promise. Plug in your own numbers.
Email 1 · about a week after it arrives

The check-in.

Ask how it's going and give one tip for using what they bought. No discount. This one builds trust for the next two.

Example · home goods store
Subject: How's the rack holding up, Dana?Dana, Your walnut rack should have landed last week. One tip: put the heaviest things on the bottom two shelves. It keeps the rack steady for years. Any questions, just reply. Oak & Pine Home
Example store. Made up for this guide.
Email 2 · about a month in

The add-on.

Suggest one product that goes with what they bought, and link right to it. One product, not your whole store.

Example · home goods store
Subject: Made to fit your rackDana, Your rack has been with you about a month now. That's usually when people figure out what they want on it. If small things keep sliding through the gaps, these shelf liners fit it exactly: [product link] Oak & Pine Home
Example store. Made up for this guide.
Email 3 · 2 to 5 months in, if they haven't ordered again

The win-back.

A short note and a small thank-you code.

Example · home goods store
Subject: A thank-you from Oak & PineDana, It's been a few months since your rack arrived. Thanks again for buying from a small shop. Here's 10% off your next order with code THANKS10: [store link] Oak & Pine Home
Example store. Made up for this guide.
Before you send

Four rules.

  • Each email is about what that person bought. Not one sale blast to everyone.
  • When they buy again, start the clock over.
  • Marketing emails need an honest From name and subject line, your business address, a note that it's an ad, and an unsubscribe link. That's the law (CAN-SPAM).
  • Track it. Check your returning customer number every month.
Done for you

Raising LTV by hand doesn't scale. Email Butler does it for you.

Every buyer gets their own follow-up emails from their Shopify order, at the right time. No blasts. You never write a word.

See my free sample emails Free. Just give us your website. No card needed.

Sources

  1. SimplicityDX, Brands losing a record $29 for each new customer acquired (Jul 19, 2022).
  2. Reichheld & Schefter, E-Loyalty: Your Secret Weapon on the Web (Harvard Business Review, Jul 2000; Bain & Company).
  3. Klaviyo, 2026 email marketing benchmarks (183,000+ Klaviyo customers; page dated 2026).
  4. Shopify Help Center, Customers reports (checked Oct 2026).
  5. FTC, CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business.

This guide is general information, not legal advice.